Thursday, June 26, 2008, 12:18 AM - Immigration
Posted by Administrator
Do people really debate illegal immigration? Isn't that roughly akin in logic to debating whether the sky is blue?Posted by Administrator
I could go on with some massive tome about why illegal immigration is bad, what steps should be taken to effectively curtail it, but honestly, I don't feel like it right now. That said, I just heard another TV "talking head (aren't most of those people completely insufferable?)" defend illegal immigration on the basis of one particularly obnoxious point, and the moment wormed its way under my skin just enough to prompt this piece.
How many times have you heard proponents of benevolence toward illegal immigrants defend their position, in whole or in part, on the basis that Americans should be grateful they're here, because they do the jobs no one wants?
When they say "no one," that is code for white Americans, although you never hear anyone come out and say that. In other words, whites, more than browns or blacks, supposedly believe that unskilled manual labor is so far beneath them that they (I guess "we," as I'm one) should be thrilled that illegals have chosen to invade our country because, of course, "we" don't want these jobs. What a pile of garbage.
I don't believe that any job, no matter how unskilled, is beneath me. Personally, I have always tried to find work at things I truly enjoy doing and which present an outlet for intellectual expression, but that does not mean those things I don't necessarily enjoy and which don't provide such an outlet are beneath me - it just means I would prefer doing something else.
Beyond professional satisfaction, the real issue is compensation. If the defenders of the illegal invasion were honest, they would fully complete the thought when expressing it; the complete thought is, "Illegal immigrants do jobs no one wants to do for the same wage rates at which illegals are content to do them." There is no such thing as a job no one wants; there are only those jobs that people cannot accept because they don't pay enough. There are countless examples of people who are currently in the midst of spending their working lives in jobs they don't enjoy very much...but do so because the compensation, either through wages, benefits, or some combination of the two, is so great that they aren't willing to leave. I'll bet that a lot of people who wouldn't currently consider working in the fields harvesting vegetables, for example, might do the job if it paid $10 an hour to start, provided production-based incentives, and included solid benefits. Would that drive up the cost of the vegetables to consumers? Sure it would, but that is how (truly) free markets work. Plus, you're already paying a lot more for your vegetables anyway, just in a different form: A portion of your taxes have long been used to pay farm subsidies, and are also used to pay for the costs of social services used by illegals.
Let me ask you something; if illegal immigrants were nowhere to be found in America, do you think all of the unskilled labor positions would remain unfilled? That's the silly argument that too many people here seem to stupidly accept - that without illegal immigrants, jobs they readily do now would never get done. Do you really believe that?
Shut the border; end tax-funded corporate subsidies and social services to illegals, and return the resulting savings to the American taxpayer; let the free market decide the pay scale. Only then can we see if there is really such a thing as a job no one wants.
By: Robert Yetman
Robert G. Yetman, Jr. is an op-ed columnist and financial editor at http://www.christianmoney.com


Search this Site



